Both lovers and haters of the iPad have been quick to point out that the iPad isn’t a laptop or netbook killer. They point to the closed OS, the difficulty getting files on/off the device, and the lack of Flash as “proof” that the iPad is pretty much just an entertainment device, and not much more than that.
I beg to differ.
A true geek finds workarounds to problems, rather than simply throwing their hands in the air and bemoaning the limitations of their device. A true geek finds a way to make it work. At least, that’s how I feel about it. Maybe that’s because of my roots; after years providing support for IBM’s OS/2 and then proselytizing Linux, finding a way to “make things work” is almost second nature to me and seems, to me, to be the defining characteristic of the hardcore geek. After all, Microsoft seemed almost deliberate in blocking many Windows applications from running in Win-OS/2, and the same holds true even today for running Windows applications under Linux. The code monkeys are constantly tweaking WINE to get more and more applications working properly, and those of us who simply cobble together solutions are still, to this day, trying to figure out how to make things work outside the software environment the applications or hardware were designed for.
From what I can gather, critics and fans have listed these as reasons why the iPad cannot be considered a laptop replacement:
1) You have to activate it in iTunes before you can use it
2) There is no easy way to transfer files from a computer directly to the iPad
3) You can only run software Apple has given its stamp of approval
4) You can’t use any hardware you want with it (such as game pads, joysticks, printers, etc.)
5) I can’t play my Flash-based games because Apple hates Adobe!
So, my response to these reasons:
1) So what? I’ve plugged my iPad into a computer only once or twice since purchase. I have an iMac at home, and another at work. I don’t consider plugging my iPad into iTunes for activation any different than the steps you have to take to set up your laptop for the first time, and copy your documents over to it.
2) This is true, and yet not. I’ve been a Dropbox user for quite some time, and have the Dropbox app installed on my iPad. Through the Dropbox app, I can read any document and view any image file I have saved to Dropbox…and anything I truly need to work on is saved to Dropbox. There are a host of other applications that provide similar functionality, and more on the way. QuickOffice for iPhone works on the iPad, even if it looks like crap…and I expect the folks at QuickOffice will have their iPad suite of applications ready for purchase any day now. For those who don’t know, QuickOffice can pull files from MobileMe, Google Docs, and Dropbox, among other sources.
The other option is to email a document to yourself, and then open it in Pages, Numbers, or Keynote for iPad. This really isn’t that difficult…I do it from Dropbox all the time when I need to edit an existing document that I don’t have in Pages or Numbers yet. Not that big of a deal, IMO.
3) Don’t really care. There is a wide enough variety of apps that I have yet to find something I can’t do with the apps available through the App Store.
4) True, but how often do you lug a joystick around in your laptop bag? For that matter, how many laptops out there are good gaming rigs to begin with?
5) Ahh, but you can! You just can’t do it directly. I’m a Farmville fanatic, and have tested this a couple of times…you CAN play Farmville (a Flash-based game), for example, on the iPad…just a bit indirectly. See, I have LogMeIn installed on my desktop computers, and have LogMeIn Ignition installed on both my iPhone and my iPad. When I want to do something that requires Flash, all I have to do is a remote login via LogMeIn Ignition, and voila! I just use my desktop, via the iPad, to view or run whatever software I want! It’s a bit slower than if I were sitting at the computer, but not terribly so.
So, here’s my final word: you CAN have an iPad replace your notebook/netbook computer…IF you are flexible in your computing needs and think through some decent workarounds. It might be a little frustrating to get everything set up, if you don’t enjoy the challenge…but I LOVE a good geek challenge!